Skip to content

Your Bag

There is nothing in your cart. Start shopping to fill it up!

Article: Top 7 Best Baby Crib Mattresses

best baby mattress, best baby crib mattress, baby crib mattress, organic crib mattress

Top 7 Best Baby Crib Mattresses

Non-Toxic Crib Mattresses Trusted by Parents, Loved by Babies

At Piccalio, our enthusiasm for baby gear drives us to independently curate our favorite products. If you make a purchase through the links on our site, Piccalio may earn a commission.

Updated

A good night's sleep is a top priority for new parents. Gain peace of mind by using a high quality crib mattress that's free of chemicals, yet comfortable for your baby. Discover the best baby mattresses you can trust to help your baby have a peaceful sleep.

What to Look for in a Baby Crib Mattress

Picking out the right baby crib mattress is a matter of safety and comfort. The American Academy of Pediatrics recommends choosing a firm mattress. This helps reduce the risk of sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS).

You can test the mattress firmness when you put your baby down on the mattress. According to the AAP, this means your baby shouldn't make an indent on the mattress when lying on it. 

Also, be sure to pick the correct mattress size. A standard-size crib measures 28 inches wide by 52 inches in length. A standard crib mattress should fit tightly within the crib. The Consumer Product Safety Commission says a full-size crib mattress should measure at least 27 1/4 inches x 51 1/4 inches.

Additionally, check the thickness of the crib mattress. A crib mattress should be 6 inches thick or less.

If you have a mini crib or a differently shaped crib, be sure to purchase a mattress that will fit.

Many crib mattresses are manufactured with harmful chemicals. Offgassing of foam is a common hazard. Fortunately, there are many non-toxic and organic crib mattress options, including those listed below. You can avoid harmful chemicals by choosing mattresses that are GOTS or Greenguard Gold Certified.

Types of Baby Crib Mattresses

Parents can choose from two main types of baby crib mattresses: spring mattresses and foam mattresses.

A coil or innerspring mattress features steel coils surrounded by soft cushion materials. Generally firmer, these mattresses are also heavier and tend to last longer. 

Foam mattresses may be made of a variety of foam materials including polyurethane foam. However, newer models are made of safer materials such as food grade polymer or natural rubber. 

The Best Baby Crib Mattresses

Discover crib mattresses made with safe materials you can trust.

1. Best Breathable Crib Mattress: Newton Crib Mattress - $299

best baby mattress, best baby crib mattress, baby crib mattress, organic crib mattress

Soft, yet firm, this breathable mattress comes with a choice of mattress cover color. This crib mattress also comes in a mini crib size if you prefer.

This breathable crib mattress gives parents peace of mind, as baby can breathe easily even if they roll onto their belly.

The removable cover is machine washable, an absolute must for busy parents. You can also wash the food-grade polymer core.

If having a waterproof mattress is important to you, choose the waterproof option. This mattress cover features a waterproof toddler side, protecting the mattress and making clean-up a piece of cake.

Highlights:

  • Greenguard Gold Certified
  • Breathable design
  • Washable
  • Ideal from infancy through toddler years

2. Best Organic Crib Mattress: Avocado Organic Crib Mattress - $349

best baby mattress, best baby crib mattress, baby crib mattress, organic crib mattress

Your baby will rest peacefully on this crib mattress featuring all organic materials. Each Avocado mattress is crafted with organic cotton, wool, coconut husk, and latex. Plus, this mattress is made in a sustainable way with environmentally-friendly materials. Buy it with a clear conscience. 

Highlights:

  • Greenguard Gold Certified
  • Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS)-Certified Organic Product
  • Two-sided mattress with a firm side for infants and softer side for toddlers

3. Best Combination Infant and Toddler Crib Mattress: Saatva Crib Mattress - $355

best baby mattress, best baby crib mattress, baby crib mattress, organic crib mattress

This ideal infant sleeping surface includes a breathable layer of GOTS-certified organic cotton and a firm innerspring mattress. The springs help maintain a firm surface all across the mattress. Additionally, natural rubber and eucalyptus fiber ensure the mattress is comfortable.

Highlights:

  • Greenguard Gold Certified
  • Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS)-Certified materials
  • Breathable top layer keeps your toddler cool
  • Washable water-resistant cover
  • Two-sided mattress with a firm side for infants and softer side for toddlers

4. Best Environmentally Friendly Crib Mattress: Lullaby Earth - $279

best baby mattress, best baby crib mattress, baby crib mattress, organic crib mattress

Lullaby Earth's best baby mattress has earned multiple awards and certifications. The brand uses recycled materials, creating an environmentally friendly product. Various organizations including Green America and American Sustainable Business Network recommend this mattress.

Highlights:

  • Greenguard Gold Certified
  • Breathable cover improves safety for infants
  • Washable cover
  • Two-sided mattress with a firm side for infants and softer side for toddlers

5. Best Organic Cotton Mattress: Naturepedic Cotton Crib Mattress - $269

best baby mattress, best baby crib mattress, baby crib mattress, organic crib mattress

Choose from a selection of mattresses including the Naturepedic organic breathable crib mattress and classic. Nataurepedic offers non-toxic crib mattress pads featuring a choice of innerspring and a lightweight core called "wavesupport."

Unlike many other mattresses, it has a waterproof cover, which is a major plus. From blow-out diapers to spit-up, a waterproof cover makes clean-up simple and straightforward. 

Highlights:

  • Greenguard Gold Certified
  • Waterproof coating offers easy cleaning
  • Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS)-Certified materials
  • Two-sided mattress with a firm side for infants and softer side for toddlers

6. Best Award-Winning Crib Mattress: Sleep Moonlight Little Dreamer Crib Mattress - $199

best baby mattress, best baby crib mattress, baby crib mattress, organic crib mattress

If you love the feel of a foam mattress, try this environmentally-friendly, non-toxic crib mattress. The waterproof cover makes for easy clean-up, even if your baby soaks through their diaper in the middle of the night. This mattress has also won multiple awards, including Gold in the Mom's Choice Awards in 2024.

Highlights:

  • Greenguard Gold Certified
  • Waterproof cover
  • Two-sided mattress with a firm side for infants and softer side for toddlers

7. Best Hypoallergenic Crib Mattress: Babyletto Pure Core - $189

best baby mattress, best baby crib mattress, baby crib mattress, organic crib mattress

Your baby will sleep well on this hypoallergenic mattress. Protected by a waterproof cover, the polyester core is recyclable. This lightweight mattress is also thinner than some, measuring 5 inches thick.

Highlights:

  • Greenguard Gold Certified
  • Waterproof cover
  • Two-sided mattress with a firm side for infants and softer side for toddlers 

Choosing the Best Baby Crib Mattress

The above baby crib mattresses all fit standard sized cribs and offer a non-toxic solution you can purchase with confidence. Which will you pick? Let us know your thoughts on the best baby mattress in the comments below.

Sources:

  1. American Academy of Pediatrics
  2. Consumer Product Safety Commission

Posted in: 0 - 3 Months, 12 - 18 months, 18 Months - 3 Years, 3 - 6 months, 6 - 9 months, 9 - 12 months, Our Favorites


Leave a comment

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

All comments are moderated before being published.

Read more

Toddler snacks, healthy toddler snacks, snack ideas for toddlers
In the kitchen

The Ultimate List of 32 Toddler Snacks

I've raised three toddlers, and they were snack monsters, now graduated to snack beasts. In fact, I'm pretty sure my oldest survived almost exclusively on snacks and indignation until he turned fiv...

Playroom design, Montessori toys, Montessori furniture
Playroom

At Home with Brittany Xavier: An LA Mama Updates her Playroom with Piccalio

Brittany Xavier, an LA mother to three, recently gave her children’s playroom a refresh with Piccalio playroom items. Xavier started out as a fashion blogger and is now widely recognized for her co...

Best Diaper Rash Cream, diaper rash ointment cream, diaper cream, butt cream, best natural diaper cream
0 - 3 Months 12 - 18 months 18 Months - 3 Years

Best Natural Diaper Rash Creams to Cure Diaper Rash Fast

When my daughter was a baby, she got the worst diaper rash. The red, irritated skin made her cry and I felt helpless. No diaper creams seemed to help soothe her sensitive skin. I changed her diaper...

Best pacifier, best pacifier for newborn, best pacifier for breastfed baby, best infant pacifier
0 - 3 Months Our Favorites

The Top 9 Safest Pacifiers for Your Newborn

If you observe a sleeping infant, you may notice them moving their tongue as if sucking while they slumber. Newborns have a natural need to suck, it's part of their instinct to feed. The best pacif...

When do babies sleep through the night, 3 month old sleep schedule, 4 month old sleep schedule, when do breastfed babies sleep through the night
0 - 3 Months 3 - 6 months 6 - 9 months

When Do Babies Start Sleeping Through the Night?

Sleep deprivation for parents in the first year of their baby's life is a nearly universal experience. Among the top concerns for new parents is when their baby will sleep through the night. Not al...

sustainable furniture, non toxic furniture, what materials of furniture are renewable and sustainable
Playroom

How We Create Sustainable Furniture and Toys for Children

One of Piccalio's core values is sustainability. As a company that creates products for children, we believe it’s our responsibility to build a brighter future for the next generation and our plane...